5 Times UK Buyers Were Misled by “Too Good to Be True” Cars

Here are five real-life examples of how people were misled – and what you can learn from their mistakes.

1. The Facebook Marketplace Bentley for £2,300

One of the most ridiculous examples shared by UK buyers was a 2016 Bentley Continental listed on Facebook Marketplace for just £2,300. It looked clean, had low mileage, and the seller said they were moving abroad quickly.

But here’s the kicker: the same photos were being used across multiple ads. Buyers later discovered that the images were stolen from older listings and the car didn’t exist. The scammer would ask for a deposit to "secure the car" before ghosting.

Lesson? Always reverse image search photos and insist on seeing the car in person before sending any money.

2. Ghost Listings With No Delivery

A buyer transferred nearly £2,000 for a Nissan Juke after being told it would be delivered to her home within 24 hours. The ad looked polished, had an honest-sounding seller, and the price seemed like a rare bargain.

The car never arrived.

It turns out the listing was fake, and once the payment was made, the seller vanished without a trace. These "ghost listings" trick you by offering home delivery and convincing communication. But if you can’t view the car in person and they’re rushing you to pay up front, it’s probably a scam.

Lesson? Never send money without seeing the car, documents, and seller in person.

3. Hidden Write-Offs and Forged Service Records

One buyer was told the car had one previous owner and full service history. It looked spotless on the surface, and the seller even had a stamped book.

After purchase, a proper history check showed the car had been written off (Cat S), had four previous owners, and the service stamps were fake. The listed garages had no record of ever servicing the vehicle.

Lesson? A clean-looking V5C or service book doesn't mean it's genuine. Always run a vehicle history check to confirm write-offs, ownership changes, and MOT records.

4. Dealers Pretending to Be Private Sellers

Some UK car dealers are posing as private sellers to avoid accountability. This tactic removes many of your consumer rights if something goes wrong post-sale.

In one example, a buyer thought they were dealing with a private owner. But the car had been listed under multiple names and contact numbers. When the car broke down a week later, there was no way to track the seller.

Lesson? Check how many ads the seller has and where they’re located. If they’re selling multiple cars but claiming to be private, that’s a major red flag.

5. The Fake HPI and Dirty-Oil Scam

Here’s one that’s both sneaky and dangerous. A seller invited buyers over, and during the test drive, they claimed the car had a write-off record and poured dirty oil into the coolant reservoir to make it look like the engine was blown.

They flashed a fake HPI report and used scare tactics to knock the price way down, then tried to buy the car on the spot. The goal? Trick the seller into accepting a rock-bottom offer based on false problems.

Lesson? Watch your car during test drives. Don’t let strangers pop the bonnet or mess with the engine unattended.

What All These Scams Have in Common

• The car is listed at an unusually low price

• Sellers are pushy about taking payment quickly

• There’s no chance to view the car before committing

• Documents don’t quite match up

• Vehicle history checks reveal very different details from what was promised

If any of those boxes are ticked, take a step back. There are always more cars out there.

How to Avoid Getting Caught Out

1. Get the registration number early and run a full car history check

2. Use TopCarCheck to spot write-offs, mileage issues, outstanding finance, and more

3. View the car in person and bring someone with you if possible

4. Match the documents – the V5C, MOT history, VIN and mileage should all line up

5. Meet at the seller's home address and avoid car parks or motorway services

6. Use secure payment methods, not bank transfers to random accounts

7. Listen to your gut – if something feels off, walk away

Don’t Learn the Hard Way

Everyone loves a bargain. But some bargains come with major baggage. If a deal seems too good to be true, it probably is.

Before you buy your next used car, make sure it’s not hiding a shady past. A quick check with TopCarCheck could save you thousands in repairs, insurance headaches, and legal stress.