Petrol vs Diesel vs Hybrid in 2025 - Which Used Car Should You Pick?

If you’re in the UK market for a used car right now, chances are you’ve asked yourself the big question: petrol, diesel, or hybrid? It’s not as simple as it used to be. Gone are the days when petrol meant “cheap to buy” and diesel meant “long-distance king.” Add hybrids into the mix - and the looming electric takeover - and things get confusing fast.

But don’t stress. This guide breaks down each option, showing you the pros, cons, hidden costs, and how each fuel type stacks up in 2025. By the end, you’ll know which used car actually makes sense for your lifestyle, your budget, and your future.

Why Fuel Type Matters More Than Ever

Choosing the right engine isn’t just about saving a few quid on fuel. It affects:

Running costs - fuel economy, servicing, and repairs.
Resale value - some cars are dropping in demand faster than others.
Insurance premiums - insurers care about engine type.
Environmental rules - cities like London are tightening emissions restrictions.

That’s why a petrol vs diesel vs hybrid debate isn’t just about preference - it’s about future-proofing your purchase.

Petrol Cars in 2025

Petrol cars are still the most common type on UK roads, and for many drivers, they’re the easiest option.

✅ Pros of Petrol Cars

Cheaper to buy than diesel or hybrid.
Generally lower repair costs.
Smooth and quiet drive.
Ideal for short journeys and city driving.

❌ Cons of Petrol Cars

Worse fuel economy than diesel, especially on motorways.
Higher CO2 emissions.
Resale values may drop faster as hybrids and EVs become more popular.

Best For:

City drivers.
People with low annual mileage.
Buyers who want a simple, affordable car without complex tech.

Diesel Cars in 2025

Diesel has taken a beating in recent years thanks to emissions scandals and ULEZ charges. But don’t count it out just yet.

✅ Pros of Diesel Cars

Excellent fuel economy, especially on long trips.
High torque - great for towing or heavy loads.
Longer engine lifespan (if well maintained).
Still plenty of supply in the used market.

❌ Cons of Diesel Cars

More expensive to buy second-hand.
Higher servicing and repair costs.
Hit with extra taxes and clean air zone charges.
Resale values are slipping, especially in cities.

Best For:

Drivers doing 15,000+ miles per year.
Rural drivers or motorway commuters.
People who tow caravans or trailers.

Hybrid Cars in 2025

Hybrids are the “in-between” choice - a mix of petrol and electric that’s supposed to give you the best of both worlds. In reality, it depends on the type.

Types of Hybrids

Mild Hybrid (MHEV) - uses a small battery to support the engine. Doesn’t drive on electricity alone.
Full Hybrid (HEV) - can run short distances on electric power.
Plug-In Hybrid (PHEV) - bigger battery you charge at home. Can drive up to 30 miles (or more) on electric before switching to petrol.

✅ Pros of Hybrid Cars

Lower running costs, especially in cities.
Reduced emissions - sometimes exempt from ULEZ charges.
Quiet, smooth drive.
Strong resale values compared to diesel.

❌ Cons of Hybrid Cars

More expensive to buy.
Complex systems - repairs can be pricier.
Batteries lose capacity over time.
Benefits are limited if you mostly do motorway miles.

Best For:

City drivers.
Stop-start traffic.
People who want a stepping stone before going fully electric.

Fuel Type Comparison in 2025

Here’s how petrol, diesel, and hybrid compare side by side:

Feature	Petrol	Diesel	Hybrid
Purchase Price	✅ Cheapest	❌ More expensive	❌ Expensive
Running Costs	❌ Higher	✅ Low (motorways)	✅ Low (cities)
Repairs	✅ Cheap	❌ Costly	❌ Costly (battery)
Emissions	❌ Higher	❌ Higher NOx	✅ Lower
ULEZ/Tax	✅ Cheaper	❌ More charges	✅ Exempt/reduced
Best For	City/short trips	Long-distance/towing	City + mixed driving

What About Resale Value?

This is where things get interesting in 2025:

Diesel - dropping fast in cities due to ULEZ expansion.
Petrol - holding steady but long-term demand may fall as EVs rise.
Hybrids - strong demand because they’re seen as a safe middle ground.

If you plan to sell your car in 3–5 years, hybrid is likely to keep the most value.

Hidden Costs to Watch Out For

Fuel type isn’t the only factor. Before buying, check for:

Outstanding finance - some hybrids and diesels still have loans attached.
Accident history - especially with hybrids, as battery damage is costly.
MOT and mileage checks - avoid clocked or poorly maintained cars.

A vehicle history check can reveal all of this before you commit.

FAQs

1. Are diesels being banned in the UK?
Not yet - but ULEZ and local restrictions are making them less attractive.

2. Do hybrids really save money?
Yes, but mostly for city driving. If you do lots of motorway miles, a diesel may still be cheaper.

3. What’s better for the environment - petrol or hybrid?
Hybrid wins by far, especially plug-in hybrids when used correctly.

4. Should I go full electric instead?
EVs are the future, but they’re still expensive used. Hybrids are a good stepping stone.

Final Word: Which Should You Pick?

So, petrol vs diesel vs hybrid in 2025 - which comes out on top?

Choose petrol if you’re on a budget and mainly drive around town.
Choose diesel if you rack up motorway miles and need pulling power.
Choose hybrid if you want lower emissions, strong resale value, and you do a lot of urban driving.

The right answer depends entirely on your lifestyle. The wrong answer? Buying blind. Always run a car history check before signing anything. It’s the quickest way to avoid hidden finance, accident damage, or mileage tampering.

Your perfect used car is out there - just make sure it’s not hiding an expensive secret under the bonnet.

Check Your Vehicle History Now

Enter Registration Number

Enter a UK vehicle registration to start your check

Secure checkout via Stripe